View Single Post
Old 07-22-2008, 08:21 AM   #15
alexander500
Zilvia Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Maryland
Age: 43
Posts: 299
Trader Rating: (8)
alexander500 has a reputation beyond reputealexander500 has a reputation beyond reputealexander500 has a reputation beyond reputealexander500 has a reputation beyond reputealexander500 has a reputation beyond reputealexander500 has a reputation beyond reputealexander500 has a reputation beyond reputealexander500 has a reputation beyond reputealexander500 has a reputation beyond reputealexander500 has a reputation beyond reputealexander500 has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bigsyke View Post
oil filter in general? or filter magnet? because those have been noted to do more harm.
The theory in this email suggests that there is so little or no friction or wear in a "heathy" engine that there is no need for any sort of cleaning/trapping device.

I have one of these mdp's and when I change my oil there are metal particles stuck to it. Particles that would other wise be working their way around engine and possibly causing damage.

The point I am tring to make is; this email and it's content is misleading. The author sounds intellegent, but in fact his reasoning is weak:

-Transmissions need magnetic drain plugs because they have gears and gears on gears wear making metal debis.

-Engines don't have gears, so there is no wear, so no need for a magnetic drain plug

I am not saying that if you don't have one you are going to die, rather that they are not as usless as the OP seems to suggest
alexander500 is offline   Reply With Quote