Fair Price for '95 S14

[JimmyJames]

I know you guys must get alot of these theads but I really need an opinion on this. I'm looking at a '95 5spd S14 wit 120k miles on it. Apex N1 turbo muffler with 3" header back pipes. Hotshot header. Needs a new catalytic converter (not expensive I know) and the front bumper is a little chipped up. Other than that the car is fine. Nice leather interior, security system, power locks, power windows, CD player. Exhaust looks a little rusted. . . . I can get it for $5800. The blue book value is something like $4300 for a private party sale. I understand the blue book can be inaccurate when it comes to sporty cars so I need to know from you guys is this a fair price to pay? I don't think I left out any important details... Thanks for your help.